Latest News

Mar 26th, 2018 by admin

Read Newsletter “The Lighthouse”

Read the latest edition of “The Lighthouse” to get church news, upcoming event information, a message from the Pastor and much more. Read newsletter>>

Mar 26th, 2018 by admin

Easter Sunrise at Cheeca Lodge

Matecumbe Methodist is known by tourists and locals alike for one of the best Easter Sunrise Services in the Florida Keys. Join us at Cheeca Lodge at 7am for a special worship service for you to celebrate the resurrection of Jesus Christ as the sun rises over the magnificent Atlantic Ocean. »»

Dec 16th, 2016 by admin


MUSIKGARTEN is held Monday at 10am in the Fellowship Hall and taught by Jan Grewe. MUSIKGARTEN is musical playtime for babies – 5 years old. The class fosters mental, social and emotional development. Join us!

Our Schedule

Sunday Worship Service: 11:00am
Sunday Bible Study: 9:30 am (Starting 1/10/15)
Stained Glass Workshop
Tuesday mornings 9am-12pm
Thursday evenings 7pm-9pm

Church Information

Matecumbe United Methodist Church is located at Mile Marker 81.8 (Oceanside) in the heart of Islamorada, Florida Keys.
Reverend Robert Pavey
Church office: 305-664-3661
Church parsonage: 306-664-9545

Our Mission

Practice the hospitality of Jesus Christ with visitors and members, strangers and friends in our Community.

We Welcome You

Whether you're an Island resident, regular snowbird or first-time visitor, we welcome you to worship with our small, friendly and family-oriented congregration. A Place to Call Home! Are you looking for a church while you're away from home? Are you looking for a place to share your gifts? Are you looking to refresh your faith? Are you living through a change in your life--wedding, moving, birth, death? We want to share our church home, our faith our gifts with you! Come see us on Sunday and let us welcome you in person.

Our History

We trace our roots as far back as 1894, when a one-room wooden Methodist Church was built on the beach in Upper Matecumbe Key. This building was later moved-probably floated between two sailboats - to the shore near the present-day Cheeca Lodge and Spa. The 1935 Hurricane destroyed much of Upper Matecumbe Key, including the Methodist church building. The church bell, however, was found and used to announce the worship service in a home. Through faith and hard work a new building for worship was constructed just north of the Hurricane Monument - the present location of the church.